11/18/2005

你开心就好

专辑：十一月的萧邦
歌手：周杰伦

我已经用最公平的角度来看这张专辑。周杰伦和他的拥护者常说，这是他的调调，突破不是一种必要。很有态度。既然如此，那也请不要给我们假象。

取名十一月的萧邦，很难免的我会期待有更多古典的元素在这张专辑里。对不起，我不应该这样想。亚洲天王都没有那么说，我怎么能这么想。

当然，你也可以说好听就好，为什么在乎那么多？因为他够红，因为他是创作天王，因为大家都说他的音乐够吊。杰伦的音乐绝对有态度，只不过他的态度还真的是贯彻始终，连一点变化都没有。

可是，我还是会承认他的歌是好听的。要整张专辑顺下来听，绝对没问题。要K 歌，有《发如雪》，《枫》给你K个够。要态度，《飘移》，《四面楚歌》，《蓝色风暴》（这首也太Hard Sell了，歌名摆明打广告）。怀念《屋顶》？放心，有比较普通的《珊瑚海》。

如果他没有被摆上神台来膜拜，我一定为他拍手叫好。只是，有时姿态太高，要求也会不自觉地提高。总觉得后期的杰伦做专辑时太有心机，少了随性，似乎已经完全掌握出大家爱的是什么，然后就作出什么。

推荐：发如雪，夜曲，黑色毛衣，一路向北

评分：7。5/10

更正：最佳新人入围出现错误。
轻松玩乐团这张《我要轻松玩》专辑其实是第二张。
所以，改为赖雅妍《Love》顶替。抱歉。

- --;11:02 PM

Comments:

Did you write the review yourself? I am impressed! :) Felt the same about Jay's works; they used to be impressive. Somehow his songs seem to lose their novelties. Anyway, see you around in forum.

# posted by

Anonymous : 03:22

Jay的歌曾经让我惊艳，但现在发现他没有创新，全部似曾相识。刻薄点讲，他的歌只有两种，with rap 或 without rap。
他的古典音乐修养很强吗？！拜托，只不过是一般古典音乐爱好者水平罢了，我没听出什么古典因素，只看到商业噱头。

# posted by

Anonymous : 18:11

《蓝色风暴》在打什么广告？

# posted by

chowchow : 18:16

yupyup, i write myself 1
lan se feng bao is for pepsi.

thanks for pple's comments. esp the part that his songs only got 2 kinds, got rap or without rap, haha.

# posted by

Freshmusic 档案 : 20:27

等等... with/without rap的分類也未免太擴了吧. 他的這張專輯又不是在賣他對古典音樂的修養啊.好聽就好.當然，他過去的歌曲可能比較讓人喜歡，但新專輯裏也有幾首好歌，也該歸功於他吧. 《十一月的蕭邦》裏，我個人是喜歡《夜曲》，《四面楚歌》，《珊瑚海》與《浪漫手機》. 還有，我承認說他沒什麽創新，但他其實一直可説是獨樹一幟. 像陳琦真的歌，一聼就知道歌手是誰. 最後，有關語病: Novelty can be lost once. How can something lose newness more than once?

P.S. This comment is not meant to be antagonistic.只是一些直言罷了.

# posted by

Char : 22:19

so somehow i still gave him 7.5 which is still a high marks. haha.

# posted by

Freshmusic 档案 : 00:01

char, i guess u r a diehard fan of jay?可惜，这不是你的地盘，我不用听你的。哈哈，just kidding.
我也喜欢Jay，不过那是在这张专辑之前。如果不是卖古典音乐，何必故弄玄虚叫什么劳什子的《十一月的肖邦》？！
Jay是一如既往的屌，而我才刚刚明白那不是自信而是狂妄。

# posted by

Anonymous : 21:11

haha.. ANONYMOUS... 我不是diehard fan. and 我同意：他的屌之前可能源自于自信，但現在卻帶有狂妄. 希望不會惡化至囂張，自大. 很多人獨比較喜歡他早期的作品與專輯，i.e. 《葉惠美》之前. 隨便，就如這個post的title一樣吧嘿嘿.. 大家，考試順利哦！

# posted by

Char : 00:47

i dun consider myself a wonderful music critic, but i think jay's album is a good enough album with some really outstanding tracks like ye qu, fa ru xue, feng, langman shou ji.. thus i was kind of sad to see people criticising his album. guess everyone has their own preferences. personally i liked this album better than 7LX cuz the all songs go smoothly without being too jarring. to me this is a different feel album from the previous ones so i find it ironic that ppl say that he's not changing and that he sounds too common and commercialised. isnt this the usual jay which many liked previously. jay mentioned before that he will continue this kind of style unless till the day when his albums dun sell well, then he might consider changing. just my 3 cents worth.

# posted by

李老师 : 22:20

11/18/2005

welcome

profile

links

credits